Scotland’s assisted suicide bill passes first vote in parliament after intense debate

The parliamentary debate was intense and emotional. Using the now-familiar rhetoric, advocates of assisted suicide insisted that legalization is necessary to end the suffering of the dying, with one MSP citing her mother’s death from cancer as her motive for voting in favor. Ally Thomson, the director of Dignity in Dying Scotland, claimed the vote in favor of doctor-administered lethal injections was “a watershed for compassion.”  

Sadly, those with disabilities once again found their voices ignored by the majority. In Canada, disability rights groups have been utterly unheeded by the government, even after the UN Committee on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities condemned the regime. Every disability rights group in the UK has condemned Leadbeater’s assisted suicide bill; MPs rejected virtually all safeguards for those with disabilities.  

A similar scene unfolded in Scotland. Labour MSP Pam Ducan-Glancy, the first permanent wheelchair user to be elected to Holyrood, told BBC Scotland News that she was “deeply worried” that the bill would put disabled people at risk,” and that this was the first step to making it “easier to help to die than help to live.” The bill, she said, could “legitimize a view that a life like ours, one of dependence and often pain, is not worth living.” The vote, in short, left her “heartbroken.” Her fears did not dent the celebration of assisted suicide supporters. 

Indeed, Liberal Democrat MSP Liam McArthur, who brought the bill forward, told BBC Scotland News that he was “delighted” and “relived,” calling it “a brave step” but “a compassionate one.” Two previous votes to legalize assisted suicide had failed on the first vote, but this time, McArthur said, “it is a step I believe Scotland is ready to take.” He was supported by Conservative leader Russell Findlay, Lib Dem leader Alex Cole-Hamilton, and the co-leaders of the Scottish Green Party, Patrick Harvie and Lorna Slater.  

READ: You must oppose assisted suicide even if you’re not Christian: here’s why

McArthur went further, directly contradicting the nearly unanimous fears of disability rights groups. “Denying dying Scots more choice will not enhance the lives of those with a disability,” he said. “Nor do I believe would it be acceptable for a person with a disability who meets the eligibility criteria under my bill to be denied the same choice as anyone else.” The fact that they believe, apparently, does not give him pause.  

While First Minister John Swinney, who came out against the bill in a series of powerful statements earlier this month, voted against it, the Scottish government unfortunately chose to stay neutral, and Health Secretary Neil Gray abstained from the vote. First Minister Kate Forbes and Labour leader Anas Sarwar both condemned the bill; Swinney and Forbes are both committed Christians. Swinney stated that he hoped “significant issues” with the bill could be dealt with, and former first minister Nicola Sturgeon, a staunch progressive, opposed the bill due to the potential for “coercion.” (ER: We believe she may be a 2.0 by now.)

In fact, the “slippery slope” warned of by many Scottish critics, including ex-Tory leader Douglas Ross, is an inevitability. McArthur noted that other countries had legalized assisted suicide despite these fears; those countries, particularly Canada, should enhance rather than allay those concerns. Indeed, McArthur’s bill limits (for the moment) assisted suicide to the terminally ill but does not specify a life expectancy timeline. In Canada, the first safeguard to be removed was the “expectation of reasonably foreseeable death.”  

McArthur’s bill will now be scrutinized at a second stage, and changes proposed and debated, with another vote on a final draft of the bill being held before it becomes law. The BBC noted that Dr. Gordon Macdonald, the chief executive of Care Not Killing, stated that there is still “massive opposition” to the bill and that the fight is not over yet. Stuard Weir of CARE for Scotland stated that “Our thoughts are with disabled Scots and many others who will be feeling great anxiety.”  

The vote in Scotland this week is a tragedy, but as with Kim Leadbeater’s Westminster euthanasia bill, it is possible that the legislation will lose support as the social costs become clearer during further debate. The BBC noted: “It is worth noting that a number of those who backed the bill still have deep reservations and want to see that their concerns can be addressed in the next stage of debate.”

Once again, a Western country is having the debate: Should the government prioritize the “choice” or the lives of the vulnerable? 

Source

Featured image source: https://www.humanism.scot/2024/03/28/assisted-dying-bill-for-scotland-published-marking-the-start-of-its-passage-through-holyrood/

************

Published to The Liberty Beacon from EuropeReloaded.com